Arsenal vs Tottenham: Who Handles Pressure Better?

A Premier League clash can get intense, but some games crank the pressure up to another level. Arsenal vs Tottenham is one of those matchups. It’s not just a game; it’s a full-blown derby, packed with history, pride, and emotion.

When the stakes are high, the tension is even higher. Think top-four battles or cup-deciding moments. Add in the fierce rivalry between these two North London giants, and you’ve got a showdown that feels like a must-win every single time.

This piece takes a closer look at the numbers, the tactics, and the head-to-head history to see which side really handles the heat better.

What Defines a Must-Win Game in Football?

Must-win games are fixtures where the outcome has a direct impact on a team’s season trajectory. For example, such a match can affect whether a club qualifies for Europe, wins silverware, or avoids a crisis.

Derbies

As of the 2024/2025 campaign, the derby between Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur has the following record:

• Previous meetings: 211
• Spurs wins: 67
• Draws: 55
• Arsenal wins: 89

Records show that Mikel Arteta’s men have a superior win tally with 89 to Tottenham’s 67. This dynamic is replicated in recent data. According to SportsMole, in the 2024/2025 spell, the Gunners won 1-0 at Tottenham Stadium in September 2024 before winning at the Emirates grounds, 2-1, four months later.

The dynamic in this derby affects betting markets, especially the 1X2 offerings. Arsenal’s superior win tally (89 vs 67) and back-to-back victories that year shift the odds in the Gunners’ favour. 

H2Hs in the Arsenal vs Tottenham Hotspur derby also influence the double chance, draw no bet, correct score, and scorelines. These trends also impact over/under goals, BTTS, handicap options, and outright and future markets. 

Title Deciders

Neither club have clinched the EPL title in recent years. However, in the 2015/16 term, when Leicester City won the title, Tottenham famously “came in third in a two-horse race”. In that period, Spurs drew 1-1 away and 2-2 at home to Arsenal. The four points lost were instrumental in denting their title chances.

According to TNT Sports, Arsenal (89) finished 2023/24 two points behind Manchester City (91). In the same year, the derby with Spurs ended in a 2-2 draw at the Emirates, and the Gunners won 2-3 away to Tottenham. The two points dropped in this clash proved to be a decider at the end of the title race. 

Top-Four Clashes

2024/25 saw Tottenham finish 17th on the table. The two losses to Arsenal, 0-1 (September 15, 2024), and 2-1 (January 14, 2025), contributed to this poor performance. However, they still made it to the 2025/26 CL by winning the Europa League.

In 2023/24, Tottenham were in a top-four race. However, they lost their home match against Arsenal (2-3) after they had drawn their away leg (2-2). The five points dropped were instructive, given they finished two points behind 4th-placed Aston Villa.

These patterns in title-deciders and top-four clashes affect betting markets, given the underlying pressure. This fixture’s inherent flows influence offerings to punters, like double chance, draw no bet, correct score, and scoreline options. The trends of this match also impact over/under goals, BTTS, handicap, and outright and future markets.

Arsenal’s Record in Pressure Situations

On September 28th, 2020, Mikel Arteta’s boys lost 3-1 at Anfield to extend their record against ‘big six’ sides to just two wins from 40 matches away in the Premier League.

After their 0-1 success at Old Trafford on the opening day of the 2025/26 campaign, the Gunners went 22 straight matches unbeaten against the traditional Big Six with 13 wins and 9 draws. 

The last time the North London side lost to a Big Six team was in April 2023 in a 4-1 defeat by Manchester City. 

The consistency shown since then is proof that they can be backed in high-pressure matches. This affects the BTTS, 1X2, clean sheet, and over/under goals betting markets. 

Tottenham’s Performance in Must-Win Scenarios

In case you are wondering, the Bix Six are Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, Manchester City, and Manchester United. Matches against these sides are considered high-pressure and must-win clashes.

According to StatMuse, Tottenham Hotspur’s win rate in the last 5 terms against other “Big Six” Premier League teams is 25%. They’ve been the weakest, consistently struggling to win against the others. 

So, bettors must be wary when backing Tottenham in betting markets. The affected offerings include BTTS, 1X2, clean sheet, and over/under goals betting options.

Arsenal vs Spurs Statistical Comparison

Analysis of the Final 5 Matches of the Season in the Last 5 Seasons (202/21 to 2024/25)

The red half of North London’s consistency in closing out campaigns is notable. They’ve averaged 2 points per game in the final stretch in the last five seasons. This is a hallmark of top-four resilience.

Tottenham’s volatility is evident, especially in 2024/25, where they collapsed defensively. In this run, they conceded 14 efforts in 5 matches.

Last 20 Meetings Between Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur (2015/16 to 2024/25)

Arsenal dominate the head-to-heads with 10 wins. This includes a strong run between 2021 and 2025. Six draws reflect the intensity and balance of the North London derbies. The Arsenal versus Tottenham Hotspur match is often a cagey and high-stakes affair. The Gunners have scored 7 more goals than Spurs across these fixtures, showing greater attacking edge. 

Arsenal and Tottenham Cup Finals and Semifinal Appearances in the Last 5 Seasons (202/21 to 2024/25)

Tottenham Hotspur’s 2024/25 Europa League win is their first major trophy since 2008. Arsenal’s deep CL run in that year signals elite-level competitiveness, even without silverware.

Impact on Betting Markets

Arsenal’s 2.08 average points per game in run-ins shows reliability in high-pressure fixtures. This affects the match outcome (1X2) market. Tottenham’s 1.48 result and defensive collapses lead to longer odds and reduced confidence in their ability to close out seasons.

Head-to-head derby odds are influenced by Arsenal’s 10 wins versus Tottenham’s 4 in their last 20 meetings. The Gunners’ attacking edge and Spurs’ defensive volatility affect goal-line offerings. Other options impacted include BTTS, correct score, scorecast, cup progress, outright markets, top 4 finish, and season futures.

Coaching Impact – Arteta vs Recent Spurs Managers

Mikel Arteta Effect

Mikel Arteta’s tenure has been marked by strategic evolution. He’s built a clear identity for Arsenal. According to OneFootball, the core impact has been in the defensive transformation.

The Revolving Door of Managers at Tottenham Hotspur

Between 2021 and 2025, Tottenham Hotspur have had Jose Mourinho, Antonio Conte, Nuno Espirito Santo, and Ange Postecoglou. 

Their peak solidity was in 2021/22 under Jose Mourinho. From then on, their defensive metrics have deteriorated, especially in high-stakes matches and away fixtures. In 2024/25, Tottenham Hotspur collapsed. They conceded 65 efforts at a 1.71 goals per match rate.

Common Traits of Clubs That Perform in Must-Win Matches

The primary traits include:

• Tactical clarity and adaptability
• Strong leadership and emotional resilience
• Experience in key moments
• Depth in squad and rotation strategy
• Fan support and home atmosphere

Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur possess these elements. However, the Gunners’ recent games suggest a more complete package than their neighbours. 

Responsible Gambling

Betting’s meant to be fun, not a money fix or a quick way out of debt. What you’re reading here is just advice, not a push to gamble more than you should.

Before you place a bet, set clear limits on how much time and money you’ll spend. And if you’re on a losing run, don’t try to win it back by betting bigger. Things can go wrong fast.

If you’re always thinking about betting, hiding it from people, or using money you need for other things, it’s time to hit pause. You’re not alone. Visit gambleaware.org for free, confidential help. You can also head to our responsible gaming page for more tips.